The Chartered Institute of Journalists says the Afghan resettlement super-injunction has gravely damaged the interests of democracy, freedom of the media, and the British Constitution’s ability to hold power to account.
CIoJ President Gerald Bowey said “Two governments had brought about the most extraordinary cover-up using super-injunction powers in British political and legal history. It is an unprecedented event in the historical narrative of Western democracies.”
He added: “Mr Justice Chamberlain’s reference to a “scrutiny vacuum” directly highlights the effect of the super-injunction on the ordinary mechanisms of accountability, which are supposed to operate in a democracy.
“The loss of the public’s confidence in our media and democratically elected politicians is incalculable.
“They have been prevented from knowing about and discussing a catastrophic communications blunder by a public official, the spending of billions of pounds of public money, and the immigration of thousands of people over a period of at least two years.”
The CIoJ praised the professionalism and dogged legal fight put up by podcast The News Agents, The Independent, The Times, The Daily Mail, The Daily Telegraph, The Financial Times and the Press Association. Their efforts to overturn the super-injunction were thwarted by the Ministry of Defence’s insistence in maintaining the secrecy and a ruling by the Court of Appeal.
The CIoJ says that the judiciary should never have entertained this request on any level, and that super-injunctions should never be a tool for executive governments.
Bowey said: “The Speaker of the House of Commons needs to urgently investigate why Parliament was rendered impotent, ignorant and powerless about what has happened.
“Why didn’t at least one MP raise the issue using Parliamentary privilege?
“No executive government should be permitted by the judiciary to use super-injunction powers in this way, and the judiciary are equally in the dock over how they allowed the secret side of law to be used in this manner.
“The problem for professional journalists is that we cannot assure the public that something like this will not happen again.”
Ends
Background note to editors:
The super-injunction applied contra mundum (i.e. “against the world”). It prevented those who knew about it from disclosing:
- the fact of the release by someone working for the UK Government of a dataset containing personal information and contact details of persons who applied for relocation to the UK from Afghanistan following the Taliban coup in 2021; and
- the existence of the injunction itself.
It was granted and maintained because the MOD assessed that public disclosure of the compromise of the dataset would expose thousands of people to the risk of extra-judicial killing or serious violence by the Taliban.

